Voices / SEC · Tokenization · Regulation

SEC Jurisdiction and the Definition of “Crypto Asset”

Tokenizing a ticket doesn’t make it a security. The SEC has said so itself. Its proposed Reg Crypto definition says otherwise.

Lee A. SchneiderBy Lee A. SchneiderGeneral Counsel, Ava Labs · November 19, 2026 · 5 min read Xin@

Independent contribution. Not sponsored. The author’s views are his own and are not legal, tax or financial advice.

The short version
  • The problem: proposed Reg Crypto defines a “crypto asset” as any digital representation of value recorded on a cryptographically secured ledger, so the medium, not the asset, decides coverage.
  • The contradiction: SEC staff, a commissioner and a joint SEC-CFTC release have all said tokenizing something doesn’t change what it is.
  • The fix: define crypto assets by what they are: tokens integral to a protocol that convey no debt, equity or claim on anyone’s income.

Pick up four pieces of paper: a child’s drawing, a driver’s license, a receipt from lunch, and a stock certificate. Nobody would suggest regulating all four the same way because they happen to be printed on paper. Paper is just the medium. What matters for regulation is what each document represents — art, identity, a transaction, ownership of a company. Each has its own body of law, developed over decades, suited to the thing itself.

What something is should decide how it's regulated. This principle is at risk of being abandoned as the representation of assets moves onto blockchains through tokenization. In particular, the SEC’s proposed Reg Crypto has lost this thread with its definition of “crypto asset.”

The nature of the asset matters

For centuries, law has classified things by what they are and what they do. We moved those things from paper to computer databases, and the law followed without much drama. A real estate deed in a county database is still a deed. A share held electronically through a broker is still a share. The format changed; the nature did not and the law recognized this fundamental point.

Blockchains are the next format. Tokenization is how things are represented on a blockchain, and it can be done with almost anything: a concert ticket, a loyalty point, an in-game sword, a gold bar, a bond, a song’s royalty stream, title to real property. In each case, tokenization changes how the thing is recorded and transferred. It does not change what the thing is.

So a tokenized concert ticket is still a contract for a service, governed by consumer protection law and the venue’s terms. A tokenized loyalty point is still a merchant’s promise, governed by whatever rules apply to the specific loyalty program. A tokenized share of stock is still a security, and securities law applies in full. The rule of thumb is simple: same asset, same risk, same regulation, regardless of medium.

There is one exception, and it is worth noting, because it is the source of most of the confusion. Some tokens (“protocol” or “network” tokens) are not representations of anything that exists off the blockchain. They are integral to the operation or functioning of a protocol, to pay for computation, staked to secure the network, and for other purposes. Take away the protocol and the token has no existence and no purpose. BTC, ETH, SOL, and AVAX are familiar examples.

The confusion arose as a matter of sequence. Protocol tokens came first, so for years “token” meant one of these, and how to classify them was the important question. Tokenizing ordinary assets came later and borrowed the same word. The novel case became the mental default, and people now mistakenly consider every token part of the same asset class, even though most are just well-understood assets in a new container. Reg Crypto risks falling into this trap by defining “crypto asset” in a manner contrary to the agency’s own writings.

The SEC has said the right thing

Commissioner Hester Peirce put it memorably: blockchain “does not have magical abilities to transform the nature of the underlying asset.” In January 2026, the Division of Corporation Finance confirmed that tokenizing a security does not change the legal nature of the underlying instrument, and that the analysis turns on the rights conveyed rather than the technology used. In March 2026, the SEC and the CFTC jointly sorted crypto assets into categories “based on their characteristics, uses, and functions.” It seemed like the agencies got it.

And then the SEC wrote the opposite into Reg Crypto

In August 2026, the SEC proposed Regulation Crypto Assets, a new offering framework for tokens. The proposed regulation defines “crypto asset” as “any digital representation of value that is recorded on a cryptographically-secured distributed ledger.” The proposing release says that the defined term “dictates the scope of the proposed rules.”

The definition throws out the nature of the asset in favor of a single criterion: how the asset is recorded. Not what it is. Not what it does. Not what rights it conveys. Under this definition, tokenized art, identity, tickets, and real estate all fall inside the securities offering rulebook — not because anyone thinks they are securities, but because a particular kind of database was used.

What’s more, the SEC knows this is wrong. The proposing release says the definition should cover “only those assets for which the relevant technology is a necessary feature.” That is the right line, but it is not the proposed rule, so it is not binding. And it is especially troublesome because it contradicts the rule as proposed.

Ava Labs and others have noted this deficiency in comment letters and suggested that the SEC define crypto asset by what it is: integral to the operation of a protocol, and conveying no debt, no equity, and no claim on anyone’s income. That definition describes the assets the proposed framework was built for, as acknowledged in the proposing release as well as through the proposed disclosure requirements and the default presumption that a covered investment contract exists until the “issuer” makes a filing that seeks to terminate it.

Why this is overreach

The SEC’s authority runs to securities, and only securities. The federal securities laws do not govern investments generally and they certainly do not govern commercial transactions. People buy property, gold, and art every day, and those arrangements sit outside the SEC’s jurisdiction because they do not involve securities, even though they can be investments. And the purchase of concert tickets, receiving loyalty points and other commercial transactions are also outside the scope of securities laws.

Being a security is the test, and Congress defined security with a specific list of assets. The definition does not reference the medium on which an asset is recorded. Congress focused on the nature of the asset, not the format.

The SEC might respond that the Reg Crypto definition is merely a label for an optional framework. But look at how the proposed regime actually works. It has a procedure for an asset to exit an investment contract but no procedure for establishing that it was never inside one. The burden always runs in one direction. In practice, coverage is the default and release must be earned.

Respect jurisdictional limits

Boundaries are not technicalities. They are what make an agency's authority legitimate when it does act. An agency that respects the edge of its jurisdiction can regulate vigorously inside it; an agency that sets its own perimeter by reference to a storage format has stopped treating the edge as real. After Loper Bright courts will no longer defer to an agency’s reading of a statute.

The SEC has already said, in its own words and more than once, that the nature of the asset is what matters. It should finish the thought and put that principle where it counts: in the rule.

Lee A. Schneider
About the author

Lee A. Schneider

General Counsel, Ava Labs

Lee A. Schneider is a financial services and technology lawyer with extensive experience in blockchain, FinTech and global regulation. Lee serves as General Counsel for Ava Labs.

Read more about Lee →

Share your voice

Are you an expert in crypto law, policy, markets or technology? Voices is where you can share your view with Cryptoweek readers, in your own words and under your own name.

Pitch a piece