Policy / Prediction markets

An appeals court sides with Maryland over Kalshi in a 2-1 ruling, the third of four appellate decisions favoring state oversight of prediction markets, as a CFTC deadline nears

A federal appeals court on Wednesday sided with Maryland in its fight with the prediction market Kalshi. The US Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit, in a published opinion, affirmed a district court's decision to deny Kalshi a preliminary injunction against Maryland gaming officials. Judges Roger Gregory and Thacker joined the court's short opinion, and each wrote a separate concurrence, while the third judge on the panel, Judge Benjamin, dissented, making the vote 2-1. Gregory wrote that the federal Commodity Exchange Act does not clearly displace a state's long-standing authority over gambling. Kalshi's spokeswoman called the result "splintered," with three contradictory opinions, CoinDesk reported.

CoinDesk counts the ruling as the third of four appellate decisions that favor state oversight. Maryland's attorney general said Kalshi must meet the same consumer-protection standards as other sportsbooks in the state.

The CFTC, led by Chairman Mike Selig, and the industry argue that the contracts are swaps, which would put them under exclusive federal control. CoinDesk reported that a 30-day CFTC demand that exchanges offer contracts in all 50 states is nearing its deadline, and that complying could defy court orders. Kalshi did not say what it will do, and CoinDesk said only a Supreme Court ruling would settle the split.

This story is reporting and analysis. It is not financial, legal or tax advice.