Policy / Congress

French Hill and Bernie Moreno say the Clarity Act has missed its window this year, and split on how much regulators can do without it

An entrance to the Cannon House Office Building on Capitol Hill in Washington. File photo. Photo: Rsparks3 / Wikimedia Commons (CC0)

Two lawmakers who have worked on crypto legislation said on Thursday that the Clarity Act, the bill that would divide oversight of crypto markets between the SEC and the CFTC, will not pass this year. Speaking in separate interviews at the Capitol Crypto Forum hosted by The Hill and The Block, Senator Bernie Moreno of Ohio was asked what could realistically happen in the lame-duck session and answered "Zero. Zero." Representative French Hill, the Arkansas Republican who chairs the House Financial Services Committee, said the chances were not high, though lawmakers never give up hope.

The bill passed the House but stalled after a failed Senate vote in September. Both men blamed delays. Moreno said the text grew from about 300 pages to about 600.

They differed on what regulators can do in the meantime. Moreno said the SEC and CFTC could achieve about 80 percent of the framework with careful rulemaking over the next two years, though he said Congress should still pass the bill. Hill said agency rules can be reversed and cannot give the same permanent certainty as a law, and called having stablecoin rules without a market structure law a big mistake.

What comes next: Moreno said he would consider restarting talks from the House-passed bill.

This story is reporting and analysis. It is not financial, legal or tax advice.